Originally posted on my Facebook page on the day after David Cameron stepped down as PM and Theresa May took the carving knife to his Cabinet.
1. David Cameron remains a class act. Of course, he had no alternative
but to step down after accidentally leading us out of the EU, but
nothing in his six-year tenure of the office of Prime Minister became
him like the leaving of it. I never voted for the man, and probably
never would have done, but he even had me in tears during his leaving
speech outside Number Ten, with his references to his family followed by
the group hug on the doorstep. It was a reminder that behind all the
political drama of recent weeks was a very human story about a family
suddenly forced to leave their "lovely" home - in little Florence's
case, the only one she had ever known.
2. It is good to see that,
despite the post-factual, "we've had enough of experts" spasm of the
Brexit vote, experience remains a prized commodity in British politics
and that the most experienced candidate for the Conservative leadership
eventually won the day. Three of the last four Prime Ministers acceded
to the top job in their 40s. Theresa May is 59 and I, for one, find it
oddly reassuring that once again we have a Prime Minister and Chancellor
who are both older than I am.
3. George Osborne and Michael Gove
finally have their just reward for their years of plotting and
backstabbing. Theirs is a deeply unpleasant little clique and it is
completely understandable that Mrs May saw no place for it in her
government. I just hope she doesn't come to regret her failure to abide
by Michael Corleone's famous dictum - "keep your friends close, and
your enemies closer." Gove and Osborne will be dangerous enemies in the
years to come.
4. In terms of other Cabinet departures, I am
particularly pleased to see the back of John Whittingdale and Nicky
Morgan. Whittingdale's constant efforts to undermine the BBC and
attempts to privatise Channel 4 posed an existential threat to two great
journalistic and cultural institutions. Similarly Morgan's attempt to
force academisation on schools would have wrecked primary education in
this country and will hopefully now be consigned to that bit of St
James' Park where they can't quite get the mower.
5. Although
there have been some well-deserved promotions - Amber Rudd, Justine
Greening, James Brokenshire - Mrs May has at times today appeared to
value loyalty over ability. There is probably a reason why Damian Green
and David Lidington reached the age of 60 without previously achieving
Cabinet office. Similarly the appointment of her former Home Office
junior Karen Bradley to the culture gig had a whiff of the old
chumocracy about it.
6. There are some obvious hospital passes
for the Brexiteers Mrs May has promoted. Andrea Leadsom at DEFRA gets
the job of explaining to the farmers that Brexit won't leave them better
off and that the UK won't be able to pick up all the EU farm subsidies
they have enjoyed for so many years. Priti Patel at International
Development gets to run a department which, three years ago, she
suggested should be abolished.
7. In any reshuffle there is
always one bit that doesn't go to plan and this year it concerned Jeremy
Hunt. It seems clear he was on his way out of the Department of Health
only for rumours of his demise to prove greatly exaggerated. My guess is
that Mrs May had someone else in mind for the job and that someone
turned it down. Either way an opportunity has been missed to detoxify
the junior doctors' dispute by moving a man who has become a hate
figure.
8. In terms of reorganising Whitehall departments, Mrs
May has made a good start but should have gone further. The Cabinet is
far too big and ideally needs to be slimmed down to about 12-15 members.
Liam Fox's new international trade role and Priti Patel's
international development role should ultimately be combined, as Ms
Patel has herself previously suggested. Separate Cabinet ministers for
Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland and English local government are a
hangover from the days when everything was run from Whitehall, and
should surely be replaced by a single Department for Devolution -
although I could understand if Mrs May decided that was one for another
day.
9. Looking at the
bigger picture, the May government's success or failure will ultimately
depend on how it responds to the three key post-Brexit challenges:
stablising the economy, refashoning Britain's role in Europe and the
world, and preserving the Union. In terms of the first, Philip Hammond
is exactly the kind of solid, dependable figure who will reassure the
markets and has already announced a welcome shift away from Osbornomics
by postponing the deficit reduction target indefinitely. In terms of
the second, David Davis is absolutely the right person to negotiate our
departure from the EU, and if anyone can refashion Britain's role in the
wider world, Boris can.
10. Finally, the Union. Those who know
me well know that my principal reason for voting Remain on 23 June was
the fear that a Leave vote would break up the UK, and if Mrs May's words
outside Number Ten on Wednesday and her decision to visit Scotland
today are anything to go by, she shares that concern. The Union is
indeed a precious, precious bond, but one which has been stretched to
breaking point over the course of the Cameron years. If Mrs May can
repair those bonds, and manage not to go down in history as the last
Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, I think that will be quite some
achievement.